Friday, November 9, 2012

David Wright v. Chase Headley


Today is the one year anniversary of Metsrospectus. A year ago today I wrote this article about Reyes losing  the Silver Slugger to Tulo, one year later here we are talking about another Met not winning awards.

In the past week the Padres 3b Chase Headley Lamar won both the NL Gold Glove and Silver Slugger both awards I feel belonged to David Wright. One of the most frequent reasons I hear cited is how well Headley did on such a poor team. The Padres were actually a better team than the Mets this year finishing with two more regular season wins and finishing in the same place in their division. Let's take a quick look at the pertinent stats of the two men.

Player
WAR
AVG
OPB
SLG
HR
K%
UZR
Wright
7.8
.306
.381
.492
21
16.7
16.8
Headley
7.5
.286
.351
.498
31
22.5%
6

Defensively I think Wright was the better player. Traditional defensive metrics have them with basically identical years. When we move to the more advanced metrics Wright clearly had a better year putting up a UZR significantly higher than Headley. I am fairly certain that the managers who voted did not factor UZR into their decision making process but ten additional runs saved is fairly significant.

On the offensive side I think it is close but I would have to give the edge to Wright. Wright led Headley in BA and OBP by decent margins and effectively tied him in SLG. The one area where Chase did soundly beat wright is homers. An additional ten home runs is a fairly decent margin and doubly impressive since he plays in a pitchers park. Another downside to Chase is his high strike out rate. Headley whiffs in about a quarter of his at bats which is fairly significant. I think if forced to choose a starting 3B for their team any rational fan would choose Wright over Headley. It is a shame that with the phenomenal year Wright had he will not be honored in any way, be it with a Silver Slugger, Gold Glove or spot as an All Star starter.


Thursday, November 8, 2012

Dickey awarded BBA top pitcher award.

R.A. Dickey was the recipient of the Baseball Bloggers Alliance "Walter Johnson" Award, given to the top pitcher in each league. Read about it here.

Wednesday, November 7, 2012

Goodbye Jason Bay



Jason Bay is gone and I have to say I am pretty pleased. Obviously it hurts that we are just throwing away 21 million dollars but at this point it was the most logical move and shows some real maturity on the part of the front office. Baseball logic often dictates that a team must start a player who they paid a lot of money too just to get the value of their purchase, even if that player is actively hurting the team. This appears to be what the Mets were doing with Bay over the last few years. A player owed 400k putting up Bay's numbers would have lasted about two weeks before being sent to Buffalo.

2010 and 2011 represented serious down years from Bay. He went from being a 30 homerun guy to hitting six and then twelve. 2012 was just downright awful. Bay was one of the worst players in baseball and posted a -.8 WAR, actually costing the Mets about a game through his poor play. Simply not having Jason on the team makes the Mets better.

In the next few days we are going to hear a lot about Bay and the way he was treated as a Met. People always say that fans are too harsh and that Jason was a great clubhouse presence and a hard worker. No one denies this. I am sure that on a personal level Bay is a very good guy but that does not separate the fact that he is an awful baseball player right now. I think we all need to understand that when we talk about ball players we are always talking about them in the context of baseball. Albert Belle is probably a nice guy, he was just mean on the field. Chipper Jones is not a bad person, I just hate him for beating the Mets. So keep in mind as we bash Bay in the next few days that we are bashing a poor performance  in relation to an amount of money paid for services and an expectation of what he would produce. Jason Bay does not suck as a person, just at baseball.

Tuesday, November 6, 2012

I'm worried.

With each day that passes I am getting more and more worried that the Mets aren't going to resign Dickey. At this point my theory is that they are waiting for Dickey to win the Cy Young when his trade value will be at it's absolute highest then move him to another team. Most reports seem to indicate that the Mets will seek 1-2 near major ready prospects for the Dickster.

Frankly this just dosen't make sense to me. I am a big believer that we can never bet on something happening we haven't seen happen before. As a full time knuckeballer R.A. has had three stellar seasons, all well above the typical age in which pitchers regress. Now after his best season yet people are starting to say that 38 is too old and he will now start to regress. The evidence just isn't here to support this. 38 is old for a baseball player but not really all that different than 36 or 37. Knuckleballers typically pitch into their 40's and their is no reason to believe that Dickey wont have 5-6 more productive years and even that his best years may be ahead of him.

I also have to say that at this point I am not all that interested in prospects. Dickey is a major league ace right now and will be for a few more years. The odds we trade him for anyone that will ever put up numbers similar to his is incredibly low.

I just don't know what I will do if the Mets ditch Dickey. He is without a doubt my favorite Met of all time and seeing him another team would be brutal. Let's keep up hope he will be a Met for years to come.

Thursday, October 25, 2012

26 years ago

I wanted to repost my favorite quote about 1986 in honor of today's anniversary:



"I'll always be grateful for the dream season of 1986. In a corner of my mind I will stand forever with my bat cocked, waiting for the two-one pitch from Calvin Schiraldi." - Gary Carter

The '86 Mets were really good.

Today is the 26th anniversary of the greatest day in Mets history so I decided to take a quick look at the roster for that team and where they stacked up using WAR. WAR was neither invented nor calculated in the 1980's so you not be familiar with these rankings for this team. The 1980's were like the statistical wild west, pitchers wins still reigned supreme and Keith Hernandez once lead the league in gwRBI.

Name
WAR
Keith Hernandez
5.9
Lenny Dykstra
4.6
Gary Carter
3.9
Darryl Strawberry
3.5
Wally Backman
3.2
Mookie Wilson
3
Kevin Mitchell
2.8
Ray Knight
2.8
Howard Johnson
1.4


Look at this, they have eight guys with a WAR over two (almost at three). The level of consistency here is just fantastic, having your seven and eight hitters be three WAR guys is such a huge benefit that very few current teams have had. For some comparison the 2012 Mets had one player with a WAR that would have fit in here (Wright at 7.8) with the next closer player being Ruben Tejada with a 2.1. Scott Hairston, a bench player, had a WAR of exactly two while every other player came in under that mark. The 1986 Mets were an offensive powerhouse from lead off through the eighth spot. Let's take a quick look at the pitchers:

Name
WAR
Dwight Gooden
4.8
Bob Ojeda
4.2
Sid Fernandez
4
Ron Darling
3.4
Rick Aguilera
1.6


Again the name of the game here is consistent goodness. 4.8 is not going to lead the league in WAR for pitchers but it is very good, the more important thing is that the next three guys are also excellent pitchers. These were consistent guy capable of going out every night and pitching effective, quality starts.

This was just a magical team. Mets fans may deal with a lot of pain and heartbreak but through it all there is always 1986, a moment of true greatness which no number of disappointing seasons can take away. There is always this:

Wednesday, October 24, 2012

Are we seriously not talking about resigning R.A. Dickey?


Recently Metsblog had a poll regarding how the Mets should handle Dickey's contract extension with 53.4% of respondents voting the Mets should trade him away for two top prospects. MY only question is...WHY? WHY WOULD PEOPLE POSSIBLY ADVOCATE THIS? Dickey has been one of the very few bright spots in the Mets system over the last two years and now we are talking about getting rid of him. Let's take a quick look at Dickey's numbers with the Mets:

Year
ERA
xFIP
k/9
bb/9
fWAR
2010
2.84
3.75
5.37
2.17
2.8
2011
3.28
3.95
5.78
2.33
2.5
2012
2.73
3.27
8.86
2.08
4.6


This dude is the picture of consistency. People keep talking about his age and about how hard he throws the knuckleball and frankly this is complete nonsense. Knuckleballers routinely pitch into their 40's and as for the speed at which he throws it, we don't know how that will play out, no one has ever done it before, he is literally breaking new ground. Which is why it is crazy to start making assumptions about how it will turn out. Here is what we know, these are facts:

Dickey has been a top 25 pitcher for three years.
He was the best pitcher in the NL this year.
As a Met and as a knuckler he has never pitched badly.
He can be resigned for cheap.

Reports indicate he can be had for three years and 40 millions bucks. In the history of baseball has a Cy Young winner (you know he's gonna win) going into free agency been got for comparatively less? This is a no-brainer. Give the guy a chance, it is entirely possible his best years are ahead of him. Every year the knuckleball gets better, who knows how R.A. can make it dance in 2013, hopefully the Mets make him a deal so we can find out.